When the H-1B Lottery Fails: H-1B cap- exempt vs Canada’s GTS

If you just found out you weren’t selected in the H-1B lottery, you’re not alone. In 2024, over 700,000 professionals competed for just 85,000 spots, leaving many talented individuals scrambling for alternatives. 

With your OPT or STEM OPT clock ticking down, you have two main paths forward: finding an H-1B CAP Exempt position in the US or moving to Canada through their Global Talent Stream (GTS). Both options have their advantages, but which one is right for you? Let’s break it down in simple terms. 

Option 1: Stay in the US with H-1B cap-exempt 

What Exactly is “H-1B cap-exempt”? 

The regular H-1B visa has a yearly limit (or “cap”) of 85,000 visas. But some jobs don’t count toward this cap. These “CAP Exempt” positions let you work in the US on an H-1B visa without going through the lottery. 

Who Can Hire You as CAP Exempt? 

Only certain employers can offer CAP Exempt positions: 

  • Colleges and universities 
  • Organizations connected to colleges and universities 
  • Non-profit research organizations 
  • Government research facilities 

This means you’ll likely be working in education, research, or healthcare rather than at a typical tech company or corporate office. 

The Good Parts of H-1B CAP Exempt: 

  • No Relocation Needed: Stay in the US where you’ve already built your life 
  • No Lottery: Apply any time of year with a guaranteed review 
  • Same H-1B Benefits: Includes the same legal protections as regular H-1B 
  • Keep Your Progress: Continue your path toward a US green card 
  • Family Stays Together: Your spouse and children remain with you on H-4 visas 

The Challenging Parts: 

  • Limited Job Options: Only about 10-15% of employers can offer CAP Exempt positions 
  • Often Lower Pay: Research and education jobs typically pay 20-30% less than corporate roles 
  • Career Path Limitations: Fewer opportunities for advancement in certain fields 
  • Frequent Relocation: May need to relocate to where these institutions are based 
  • Employer Lock-In: Changing to a non-exempt employer means entering the lottery again 

Option 2: Fresh Start in Canada with the Global Talent Stream 

What is the Global Talent Stream? 

The GTS is Canada’s fast-track work permit program for skilled tech workers and certain other professionals. It’s designed to bring international talent to Canadian companies quickly and without a lottery. 

Who Qualifies for GTS? 

You can qualify through either: 

  • Category A: For unique, specialized talent hired by companies referred by designated partners 
  • Category B: For workers in specific high-demand jobs (mostly tech roles) listed on the Global Talent Occupations List 

The most common qualifying jobs include software developers, computer engineers, and digital media designers. 

The Good Parts of GTS: 

  • Super Fast Processing: Most work permits approved in just 2 weeks 
  • No Random Selection: Based on your qualifications, not luck 
  • Quick Path to Permanence: Can apply for permanent residency in as little as 6 months 
  • Family Benefits: Your spouse gets an open work permit, kids get free public education 
  • Universal Healthcare: Access Canada’s medical system after a short waiting period 
  • Thriving Tech Scene: Growing tech hubs in Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal, and more 
  • Higher Approval Rate: Over 95% of GTS applications are approved (compared to roughly 30% chance in the H-1B lottery) 

The Challenging Parts of GTS: 

  • The Big Move: Relocating to a new country with different systems and culture 
  • Weather Reality: Canadian winters are genuinely cold (except in Vancouver) 
  • Income Difference: Tech salaries average 15-20% lower than US equivalents 
  • Exchange Rate Impact: Earning in Canadian dollars (worth less than US dollars) 
  • Starting Over: Building new professional and personal connections 

Side-by-Side: How They Compare 

Factor  H-1B CAP Exempt  Canada GTS 
Application Timeline  2-4 months (15 days with Premium Processing)  2-3 weeks 
Approval Rates  95%+ for qualified applicants  95%+ for qualified applicants 
Initial Visa Length  3 years  2 years 
Typical Processing Cost  $2,500-5,000 USD  $1,000-1,500 CAD 
Path to Permanent Status  5+ years typically  Often 1-2 years 
Spouse Work Rights  Limited (only certain H-4 holders)  Full work authorization 
Job Mobility  Only between CAP-exempt employers  Any qualified Canadian employer 
Average Tech Salary  $85,000-130,000 USD (in research/education)  $70,000-110,000 CAD 
Healthcare  Employer insurance required  Universal system after waiting period 

5 Key Questions to Help You Decide 

Ask yourself these questions to determine which path makes more sense for you: 

  1. How important is staying in the US to you? If you’ve built a life you don’t want to leave, focus on CAP Exempt or Day 1 CPT options. 
  1. How quickly do you want permanent residency? If this is a priority, Canada offers a much faster path. 
  1. What does your family situation require? If your spouse needs to work, Canada’s open work permits are significantly advantageous. 
  1. What field do you work in? If you’re in research, academia, or healthcare, CAP Exempt positions align well. If you’re in tech, healthcare, research Canada has good opportunities as well. 

Next Steps: What To Do Today 

If Pursuing H-1B CAP Exempt: 

  1. Update your resume to highlight research and academic experience 
  1. Search specifically for jobs at: universities, university medical centers, research institutes, and government labs 
  1. Use these job boards: Higher Ed Jobs, Academic Positions, university career sites 
  1. Network with: current employees at research institutions, professors, academic administrators 

If Pursuing Canada’s GTS: 

  1. Check your eligibility https://pathtocanada.com/us-to-canada/how-us-job-work-remotely-from-canada/ 
  1. Search for Canadian companies that have used GTS before 
  1. Use job boards like: Syndesus, Canada Job Bank 
  1. Prepare documents: degree evaluations, language test results (IELTS) 

Frequently Asked Questions 

  1. Can I switch from CAP Exempt to regular H-1B later?Yes, but you’ll need to go through the lottery system to do so.
  2. How much does it cost to relocate to Canada?Budget approximately $10,000-15,000 CAD for a family of four (including flights, temporary housing, and settling expenses).
  3. Can I travel back to the US easily from Canada?Yes, most work permit holders can visit the US, though you may need a visitor visa depending on your citizenship.
  4. What happens if I lose my job under either program?On CAP Exempt H-1B, you have a 60-day grace period to find another CAP Exempt employer. In Canada, you typically have 90 days to find another GTS-eligible position.
  5. Can I apply for both options simultaneously? Yes, there’s no rule against pursuing both paths at the same time. 

Conclusion: There’s Always a Path Forward 

Not winning the H-1B lottery can feel devastating, but remember that thousands of professionals have successfully navigated this challenge before you. Whether you choose to pursue a CAP Exempt position or embrace a new chapter in Canada, both paths offer strong opportunities for career growth and eventually permanent residency. 

The key is to act quickly, understand your options thoroughly, and make a decision that aligns with your long-term goals. Your North American dream isn’t over—it just might take a slightly different route than you originally planned. 

Disclaimer: Immigration policies change frequently. This information is accurate as of February 2025, but please consult with an immigration attorney for advice specific to your situation. 

 

 

Read More